Bomb squads on stacked benches are making it even more crucial to control rugby’s aerial battle | Ugo Monye
Rugby union is a sport of trends and of unintended consequences and what I expect to be the two most decisive factors in England’s clash with the All Blacks on Saturday are inextricably linked,Much has been made of England’s firepower on their bench – New Zealand’s isn’t bad either – and when coaches are able to call upon such quality replacements, often en masse, then the kicking battle becomes all the more important,That's because the international game is not currently as fluid as it has been which isn’t necessarily a criticism, it’s just the way things are at present; a little bit like the Premier League where set pieces and long throws are dominating,Of course we would all love to see flowing, attacking rugby but it’s really difficult,Because all elite sides favour having 13 or 14 men in the line, they all seem to adopt a blitz defence and the sheer level of physicality means it can be hard to have possession.
It means that having a good set piece and a good kicking game are paramount and the emerging trend for “bomb squads” accentuates that because less fatigue is taking hold across 80 minutes,That isn’t to say there aren’t some magical moments when teams are on transition – Henry Arundell’s try against Fiji is a great example – but it is clear to me that things are a little old school at the moment,It is not a new phenomenon that international rugby matches are decided in the final 20 minutes but Steve Borthwick deserves credit for taking what was a real weakness of England’s 12 months ago and making it one of their strengths,In last year’s autumn campaign the bench just wasn’t up to standard – Borthwick did not have the level of quality individuals needed – but that is no longer an accusation that can be levelled at him,Six British & Irish Lions including Tom Curry, who I believe is the best openside flanker in the world, demonstrate that England’s bench is a potent weapon.
It is, of course, a risk to stack your bench, all the more so when playing a side such as the All Blacks, who have a history of starting fast and blowing teams away,Borthwick will be mindful of that but this is not a vintage New Zealand side,Granted, they raced into a 17-0 lead against Scotland but in years gone by the All Blacks would have racked up 40-odd points and put Scotland well out of sight,As it was they had to win the match twice at Murrayfield,The key for Borthwick is not just having this arsenal on the bench, it is deploying it in the right way.
Evidently, just as the Springboks have done, Borthwick likes to make wholesale changes to his forward pack around 50-60 minutes.We can expect that again on Saturday but crucial will be the head coach’s ability to adapt on the hoof if he needs to.If New Zealand have raced in to an early lead he cannot afford to stand on ceremony.The Springboks are the world leaders in that regard.Against France last weekend, Rassie Erasmus changed one of his props after half an hour, replaced Siya Kolisi at half-time on his 100th cap following Lood de Jager’s red card, made the surprise move to bring on Manie Libbok at fly-half and push Sasha Feinberg-Mngomezulu to full-back and deployed André Esterhuizen as a flanker/centre.
They were inspired, proactive moves by Erasmus and he and his coaches are streets ahead of the rest of the world in that regard.Borthwick has to be prepared to be similarly brave on Saturday.If things pan out as Borthwick seems to expect, the scoreline will be close heading into the final quarter.Heavy rain is forecast so it could well be a cagey affair and there is no doubt that both sides will look to kick regularly.New Zealand’s No 1 priority when doing so will be to keep the ball away from Freddie Steward and in order to do that they will look to kick off 10 and 15 rather than 9.
Two clean, quick passes gives the full-back a far better opportunity to find space than when kicking through the scrum-half.England, for their part, will look to Alex Mitchell and George Ford to exert the kind of control they exerted over Australia and as a result the latter’s recall at fly-half is no surprise.Steward is in for a busy afternoon and Tom Roebuck’s return to fitness from an ankle injury is a huge boost for Borthwick because they are two of the best aerial operators around.Again, that may not be what spectators who value fast, free-flowing rugby want to see all the time but I’m reluctant to view England’s kicking in a negative light.The criticism was understandable at the World Cup when they were wasting overlaps to put boot to ball but now they are maximising their assets.
Sign up to The BreakdownThe latest rugby union news and analysis, plus all the week's action reviewedafter newsletter promotionDo the Springboks come in for unfair criticism for their reliance on their scrummaging ability? There are three reasons why you kick – to get territory, to get the ball back and to score.In their two matches to date England have shown how effective they can be in all three facets and on Saturday, against the side ranked second in the world, it stands to reason that they will attempt to do so again.
’Tis the season for dubious TV adverts | Letters
The issues you highlighted in your editorial are real, but please don’t think that advertisers care about them (The Guardian view on the John Lewis Christmas ad: a modern story of fathers and sons, 7 November).This ad is a shameless attempt to make consumers think they are doing something worthwhile in buying overpriced gifts in a failing store that used to share its profits with staff but hasn’t paid them any bonus in the past few years.If anything, the relentless pressure of advertising (where the Christmas season starts earlier each year) only serves to pile more pressure on people who are struggling. The cynicism of these ads – pretending to care while desperately trying to trigger the Pavlovian Christmas shopping response – is truly depressing.Chris LinwardSalford Your editorial’s claim that the new John Lewis Christmas ad was “harking back to the 1990s” and evoked “a less complicated time to be a young man” would be news to anyone who remembers that time as the era of laddism and Loaded, and the underlying unease about men’s emotional lives as shown in novels such as Tim Lott’s White City Blue and Nick Hornby’s About a Boy
US markets struggle amid tech sell-off and economic uncertainty
Wall Street came under pressure on Thursday, enduring its worst day in a month as a sell-off of technology stocks intensified.After an extraordinary rally around hopes for artificial intelligence that propelled global stock markets to record highs, fears that tech firms are now overvalued loom large.Investors are also braced for the release of a batch of official data on the state of the US economy, amid heightened uncertainty over its strength during the federal government shutdown.The benchmark S&P 500 and the Dow Jones industrial average each closed down 1.7% in New York on Thursday, while the tech-focused Nasdaq Composite dropped 2
Thames Water tried to make MP pay its legal fees of up to £1,400 an hour
Thames Water argued that an MP should be forced to pay its hefty legal costs after he represented the interests of the British public in court, a move he described as “retaliation” for pushing for government control of the crisis-hit utility, the Guardian can reveal.The UK’s highest court this week rejected Thames Water’s arguments that the Liberal Democrat MP Charlie Maynard should pay legal fees as high as £1,400 per hour.Britain’s biggest water company has been on the verge of collapse for several years as it struggles under the weight of net debt of £17bn, built up over decades since privatisation. Thames Water’s effective owners have asked for 15 years of leniency from environmental fines from the government to try to recover.Maynard was granted unusual permission to represent the public interest in a court battle over an investor bailout for Thames Water
Pound falls and UK borrowing costs rise as Reeves ditches plans for income tax hike – as it happened
Time to recap…The pound has fallen and the price of UK government borrowing rose today as investors worry over how the Labour government plans to cover its fiscal shortfall in the upcoming budget.It was all in reaction to news that chancellor Rachel Reeves was backtracking on plans to hike income tax rates, in what would have resulted in breaking the party’s manifesto pledge.However, with just two weeks to go until the 26 November fiscal event, it has left investors scratching their heads over how the chancellor plans to raise funds in order to cover policies like increased defence spending or the likely scrapping of the two-child benefit cap.Meanwhile, the FTSE 100 not only suffered from those domestic jitters, but also global fears over an AI tech bubble, which continue to drag on US stocks on Wall Street.Investors are also worried that the Federal Reserve will hold off cutting interest rates in December, and the impact of delayed data on rate decisions, following the US government shutdown
Walmart CEO Doug McMillon to step down after more than a decade in role
Walmart’s CEO, Doug McMillon, will retire next year after more than a decade in charge of one of the world’s largest retailers.John Furner, the chain’s boss in the US, will succeed McMillion as the Bentonville, Arkansas-based grocery retailer’s global CEO after 31 January.Shares in Walmart fell about 3% during premarket trading.Walmart employs 2.1 million workers across the world, including about 1
‘Red cup rebellion’: striking Starbucks baristas urge customers to stay away
At a popular Starbucks in Brooklyn’s Clinton Hill, hundreds of people – including workers, union allies and community supporters – filled the sidewalks. In 40F (4.4C) weather, picketers held signs, marched, and chanted “What’s disgusting? Union-busting!” and “No contract, no coffee!”More than a thousand Starbucks workers across the US walked off the job on Thursday in over 40 cities, marking one of the largest coordinated actions yet by the rapidly growing union movement inside the world’s largest coffee chain.The strike, timed to coincide with the company’s lucrative “red cup day” festivities, is designed to pressure Starbucks back to the bargaining table after months of stalled contract negotiations.In Clinton Hill, many potential customers who stopped by for coffee were successfully deterred, choosing instead to support the strike
‘I really enjoyed it’: new RSC curriculum brings Shakespeare’s works to life in UK classrooms
Jon Stewart on government shutdown deal: ‘A world-class collapse by Democrats’
Old is M Night Shyamalan at his best: ambitious, abrasive and surprisingly poignant
‘Harlem has always been evolving’: inside the Studio Museum’s $160m new home
‘Most of it was the conga preset on Prince’s drum machine’: how Fine Young Cannibals made She Drives Me Crazy
Groundbreaking British Museum show set to challenge samurai myths