Expert panel advises against prostate cancer screening for most men in UK
Prostate cancer screening should not be made available to the vast majority of men across the UK, a panel of expert government health advisers has said, to the “deep disappointment” of several charities and campaigners,The UK National Screening Committee (UKNSC) has instead recommended that there should be a targeted screening programme for men with a confirmed BRCA1 or BRCA2 faulty gene variant, which means they are more at risk of faster growing and aggressive cancers at an earlier age,Men in that category could be screened every two years between the ages of 45 and 61, they said,The committee found that the “harms would outweigh the benefits” if it were to recommend prostate cancer screening for all men or for men with a relevant family history of cancer, as it could lead to a small reduction in the number of prostate cancer deaths but “very high levels of over-diagnosis”,When it came to screening black men, who have an elevated risk of prostate cancer, the committee found current evidence to be “lacking and uncertain”.
In response to the committee’s draft recommendation, the health secretary, Wes Streeting, said he would “examine the evidence and arguments in this draft recommendation thoroughly”.The draft recommendation will now be open for a 12-week consultation before a final recommendation to the government is made in March.Prostate cancer is the most common male cancer, affecting one in eight men, with about 55,300 new diagnoses and 12,200 deaths every year.Despite being the second most common cancer in the UK after breast cancer, there is no screening programme in place in part due to the unreliability of the prostate specific antigen (PSA) test.One in four black men will be diagnosed with prostate cancer in their lifetimes.
Black men have a higher risk of a late-stage diagnosis of the disease than white men, but the committee did not recommend they should be screened, due to lack of data and uncertainties in the existing data.Screening of black men could lead to “high rates of overdiagnosis and overtreatment”, the committee said, with its modelling finding that an annual screening programme for black men aged between 55 and 60 would lead to 44% of prostate cancers being “overdiagnosed”.This is because some prostate cancers that are slow-growing and not aggressive would not necessarily require certain treatments.The committee estimated that about 40-50% of prostate cancer cases detected by PSA screening would be slow-growing, and that further treatment and testing for these slow-growing cancers would lead to high levels of overdiagnosis and overtreatment, “causing unnecessary anxiety and lifelong side-effects such as incontinence, erectile dysfunction and bladder problems for a cancer that would never have caused harm”.The committee concluded that screening all men for prostate cancer in the UK, regardless of their risk, would only slightly reduce the number of deaths from the disease but would lead to a “very large number of men to be overdiagnosed”.
Men with a family history of prostate, breast or ovarian cancer were also not recommended for screening by the committee for similar reasons.BRCA1 and BRCA2 gene variants are faulty genes that can increase a person’s risk of developing breast, pancreatic, ovarian and prostate cancer.About one in 300 to one in 400 people will have a faulty BRCA1 or BRCA2 gene, according to Cancer Research UK, with many being unaware of their status.People with Jewish ancestry are at a higher risk of having the faulty gene, with one in 40 Ashkenazi Jews and one in 140 Sephardi Jews being at risk.Men are encouraged to speak to their GP about getting a blood or saliva test for the faulty gene if they have a strong family history of cancer.
Although the screening committee could not give an exact figure on the number of men who would be eligible for prostate cancer screening under its proposal, it is expected to only be a few thousand men given the rarity of the gene mutation,Although some charities have welcomed the decision by the screening committee, others and some public figures have expressed “deep disappointment” that men with the highest risk of the disease would not be offered screening,Cancer Research UK said it “support[s] the committee’s conclusion that for other groups of men, there isn’t currently enough high-quality evidence that screening would do more good than harm”,Dr Ian Walker, the executive director of policy at Cancer Research UK, added: “It can miss dangerous cancers and detect ones that don’t need treatment,“Work is still needed to understand how the proposed screening programme could be delivered, and we look forward to the UKNSC setting out further details in due course.
”Prof Kamila Hawthorne, the chair of the Royal College of GPs, also supported the committee’s evidence-based approach to screening, adding: “Today’s decision by the NSC not to recommend whole-population screening of men for prostate cancer reflects the lack of evidence that PSA blood testing is reliable enough to detect prostate cancer that needs treatment,”However, the charities Prostate Cancer UK and Prostate Cancer Research, alongside public figures including Stephen Fry and Rishi Sunak, expressed “deep disappointment” at the screening committee’s decision and warned that many more men would be at risk of late diagnosis or even death from the disease,Laura Kerby, the chief executive of Prostate Cancer UK, said the decision came as a “blow to the tens of thousands of men, loved ones and families who’ve fought for a screening programme”,Kerby added: “While screening men with BRCA gene variations will save only a fraction of that, the committee’s decision is the first time they’ve recommended screening of any kind for prostate cancer,It shows that research and evidence can shift the dial and save men’s lives.
”Prostate Cancer Research said that excluding black men and men with a family history of the disease was a “serious error that ignores modern evidence and risks widening health inequalities for another generation”.Fry and Sunak, ambassadors for Prostate Cancer Research, both expressed disappointment in the decision.Sunak said that it was a “missed opportunity to make a generational difference to male health”, while Fry stated: “Men in the UK deserve so much better.”The former prime minister David Cameron, who revealed earlier this week that he had been treated for prostate cancer, also said he was “disappointed” in the decision.He added: “We are letting down too many men if we don’t push for a wider screening programme that includes all high-risk groups – and not just the men involved, but their families too, who risk losing a loved one unnecessarily.
”Streeting said: “I have always said I want to see screening in place for the most common cancer in men, provided this is backed by evidence.I want to change the NHS so it diagnoses earlier and treats faster.That aim will be balanced against the harms that wider screening could cause to men.” He added: “I will examine the evidence and arguments in this draft recommendation thoroughly, bringing together those with differing views, ahead of the final recommendation in March.“In the meantime, we will keep making progress on cutting cancer waiting times and investing in research into prostate cancer detection.
In the last 12 months, 193,000 more patients received a diagnosis for suspected cancer on time.”
Oh yes he is! Kiefer Sutherland dives into the world of panto
Hollywood megastars hit Leeds this year to make Tinsel Town, a feelgood festive comedy about panto. The 24 star, Rebel Wilson and more talk about their addiction to Greggs sausage rolls – and epic brawls with Danny DyerTwenty-odd years ago, I binged a TV series on DVD for the first time. At my mate’s house in a village outside Harrogate, I was glued to Jack Bauer shooting his way through 24. We probably only made it to episode six before surrendering to sleep for school the next day.Fast forward to the start of this year, and photos are all over the local news of Kiefer Sutherland out and about in nearby market towns Knaresborough and Wetherby
O come out ye faithful: a joyful roundup of UK culture this Christmas
The 12 Beans of ChristmasTouring to 19 December Last year, character comedians Adam Riches and John Kearns joined forces for an archly silly tribute to crooners Michael Ball and Alfie Boe. Now Riches is back with another leftfield celebrity riff as he gives his Game of Thrones-era Sean Bean impression (as seen on 8 Out of 10 Cats Does Countdown and his Edinburgh show Dungeons’n’Bastards) a yuletide twist. Rachel AroestiThe BFGRoyal Shakespeare theatre, Stratford-upon-Avon, to 7 February Are you ready for snozzcumbers and dream-catchers, for norphans and whizzpoppers? A stellar team have come together for this world premiere of Roald Dahl’s children’s classic, with a script courtesy of Tom Wells (Jumpers for Goalposts) and puppetry by the masterful Toby Olié (Spirited Away). John Leader heads up the cast for this beloved story of an orphan befriending a giant; Daniel Evans directs. Kate WyverCount Arthur Strong Is Charles Dickens in A Christmas CarolTouring to 14 December The reliably bewildered and chronically digressive one-time variety star takes his tangent-riddled festive show on tour again
Nominate your favourite Australian children’s picture book of all time
A good picture book is pure magic – and Australia has produced some of the best. Nominate your favourite hereThe best children’s picture books can be pure magic for adults, too: witty and wise prose or poetry that is a joy to read aloud, coupled with vivid, evocative illustrations that live on in the memory – and the culture – for decades.Australia has produced more than its fair share of classics, from the effortlessly educational to the cheekily irreverent, and we want you to nominate your favourite for a major reader’s poll we will run in late January: the best Australian children’s picture book of all time.To be eligible a book must be:Primarily intended to be read aloud to children who don’t yet read independently;Able to be read in a few minutes – we’re looking for a child’s picture book, rather than a graphic novel or illustrated chapter book;Written by an Australian (or someone we’ve claimed);Published in Australia.If the respondent is under 18, a parent or guardian must complete the form on their behalf
Jimmy Kimmel: ‘Thankful that we only have five weeks left in this year’
Late-night hosts recapped Donald Trump’s especially weird address at the annual Thanksgiving turkey pardon.On his final show before the Thanksgiving holiday, Jimmy Kimmel counted his blessings. “This year, I am most thankful that we only have five weeks left in this year,” he joked on Tuesday evening.Meanwhile at the White House “the presidential ketchup boat is filled to the brim and ready to go.” On Tuesday, at the “freshly paved over Rose Garden”, the president presided over the annual pardon of the turkeys, “which at this point are the only thing that Trump hasn’t pardoned this year”
Seth Meyers on Trump’s meeting with Mamdani: ‘I’ve never seen Trump this smitten before’
Late-night hosts discussed Donald Trump’s strangely friendly meeting with New York’s mayor-elect Zohran Mamdani.Seth Meyers devoted his Monday Closer Look segment to the bizarrely friendly White House meeting between Donald Trump and New York’s mayor-elect, Zohran Mamdani, where the president seemed downright pleased to be meeting the Democratic socialist that his administration has long demonized.“He looks like a five-year-old meeting Mickey Mouse,” said an amused Meyers. Though Trump had previously called Mamdani a “communist” and a “total nutjob” the president seemed charmed by the 34-year-old mayor.“I’ve never seen Trump this smitten before,” the Late Night host said
Graham Linehan cleared of harassing trans activist but convicted of damaging phone
The Father Ted co-creator Graham Linehan has been cleared of harassing a transgender activist on social media but found guilty of criminal damage of their mobile phone outside a conference in London last year.The 57-year-old flew from Arizona to appear at Westminster magistrates court in person on Tuesday, where the judgment was delivered.Linehan denied harassing Sophia Brooks on social media between 11 and 27 October 2024, and a charge of criminal damage of their mobile phone on 19 October last year outside the Battle of Ideas conference in Westminster.Judge Clarke fined Linehan £500 and ordered him to pay costs of £650 and a statutory surcharge of £200. Linehan’s lawyer, Sarah Vine KC, asked that he be given 28 days to pay the full amount
Foreign interference or opportunistic grifting: why are so many pro-Trump X accounts based in Asia?
London councils enact emergency plans after three hit by cyber-attack
European parliament calls for social media ban on under-16s
ChatGPT firm blames boy’s suicide on ‘misuse’ of its technology
Europe loosens reins on AI – and US takes them off
Macquarie Dictionary announces ‘AI slop’ as its word of the year, beating out Ozempic face