Release errors show the sorry state that prisons are in | Letters

A picture


I have considerable sympathy with David Lammy’s current predicament (Lammy says he was right not to discuss mistakenly freed prisoner at PMQs, 6 November).Our entire justice system was woefully neglected throughout 14 years of Conservative tenure.But this neglect was particularly calamitous in relation to our prisons.Rectifying the obscenity that currently passes for our prison system will require enormous government investment of public money at a time when public finances are stretched and sympathy for our prison population is low: there are precious few votes in a manifesto promise to improve the lot of prisoners.However, I feel we must look at this disgraceful situation from the standpoint of the poor prison officers who are tasked with working in these dreadful institutions.

If conditions in our largely outdated prisons are bad for the inmates, just imagine what it is like having to work in them,It must be incredibly difficult to recruit new staff to the Prison Service and nigh on impossible to retain them, leaving the service dependent on young, inexperienced, demotivated staff with poor morale who are regularly exposed to high levels of verbal and physical abuse,Being a prison officer should be a high-status profession respected by the public, personally fulfilling for the officers, well paid, with continuous training, opportunities for career development and good levels of restorative annual leave,Staff-to-prisoner ratios must be dramatically improved to enable officers to engage in the essential tasks of education, rehabilitation and preparing prisoners for reintegration following release,Currently, their role is simply to supervise the incarceration of prisoners in their cells for a large proportion of every day.

We must improve the physical, social, economic and rehabilitative aspects of our prisons, if not for the inmates, then for the poor benighted souls who have laudably chosen a career in the Prison Service, a job that few of us would be prepared to consider.John LovelockBristol Peter Walker’s analysis of the chaotic circumstances behind recent prison release errors comes as no surprise to anyone with experience of our prison system (Overcrowding, understaffing and old IT: chaotic context to prison release errors, 6 November).What the inspection reports don’t fully capture is the daily reality inside these places.Many prisoners live in unclean, rat-infested conditions that would be condemned if found in any other public building.Violence, drug use and self-harm statistics, while “gradually improving” in some places like Wandsworth, paint a picture of profoundly unsafe environments for both prisoners and staff everywhere.

There is some evidence that the drug crisis is keeping a temporary lid on behaviour, but it fuels a shadow economy controlled by organised crime groups and corrupt staff members, and creates the very instability that makes rehabilitation impossible.The prison wings may appear superficially calm, but this represents containment, not safety or progress.If rehabilitation was already a struggle under these conditions, it now risks becoming a pipedream.We cannot continue to warehouse people in Dickensian squalor with diminishing support.James StoddartProject coordinator, The Oswin Project Have an opinion on anything you’ve read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.

cultureSee all
A picture

‘I really enjoyed it’: new RSC curriculum brings Shakespeare’s works to life in UK classrooms

Act 1. Scene 1. A classroom in a secondary school in Peterborough. It is a dreary, wet afternoon. Pupils file into the room, take their seats and face the front

A picture

Jon Stewart on government shutdown deal: ‘A world-class collapse by Democrats’

Late-night hosts unleashed on Senate Democrats for caving on the longest-ever government shutdown with no assurance on healthcare subsidies from Republicans.Jon Stewart minced no words for congressional Democrats on Monday evening, hours after a coalition broke from the party and voted with Republicans to extend government funding through January with no assurances on the healthcare tax credits at the center of the 41-day stalemate. “By the way, tonight’s show will be brought to you by: I can’t fucking believe it,” Stewart fumed at the top of The Daily Show. “I can’t fucking believe it: for when the ‘I can’t believe it’ Edvard Munch scream emoji doesn’t quite convey how much you cannot fucking believe it.”“They fucking caved on the shutdown, not even a full week removed from the best election night results they’ve had in years,” he continued

A picture

Old is M Night Shyamalan at his best: ambitious, abrasive and surprisingly poignant

In August 2002, Newsweek boldly anointed the stern-faced man pictured on the cover of its splashy summer issue as “The Next Spielberg”. While some might have called this an unfair comparison to one of cinema’s most legendary figures, for a then 31-year-old M Night Shyamalan, it was a childhood dream come true. The Indian-born, Pennsylvanian-raised film-maker had whetted his cinematic appetite on the images of Jaws and Raiders of the Lost Ark, and for better or worse, would find himself chasing that same level of stratospheric fame in the early days of his career.Despite the initial acclaim of The Sixth Sense, though, Shyamalan’s reputation and audience goodwill would soon begin to nosedive as his idiosyncratic directing style rubbed against the grander ambitions of his movies. But after a temporary exodus from Hollywood and a retreat to his roots in independent cinema, Shyamalan finally returned to studio film-making in 2021 with the release of Old, a masterful high-concept thriller that rekindled the director’s longtime fascination with family, parenting and the mystifying possibility of the unknown

A picture

‘Harlem has always been evolving’: inside the Studio Museum’s $160m new home

The iconic museum, which was founded in 1968, has been rehoused in 82,000-sq-ft building providing a new destination for Black art in New York CityCall it the second Harlem renaissance. On Manhattan’s 125th Street, where a statue of Adam Clayton Powell Jr strides onwards and upwards, and a sign marks the spot where a freed Nelson Mandela dropped by, there is bustle and buzz.The celebrated Apollo Theater is in the midst of a major renovation. The National Black Theatre is preparing to move into a $80m arts complex spanning a city block. In September the National Urban League opened a $250m building containing its headquarters, affordable housing and retail space with New York’s first civil rights museum to come

A picture

‘Most of it was the conga preset on Prince’s drum machine’: how Fine Young Cannibals made She Drives Me Crazy

‘Prince’s Purple Rain guitar was in the corner of the studio and his lava lamps were everywhere. You couldn’t help but be inspired’I was in a band in Hull called Akrylykz. When the Beat came to play at the Welly club we gave them a demo tape. Then they invited us to tour with them. Later, after they split up, Andy Cox and David Steele were looking for a singer for a new band and they remembered me

A picture

Groundbreaking British Museum show set to challenge samurai myths

A groundbreaking samurai exhibition that promises to challenge “everything we think we know about Japan’s warrior elite” spanning a millennium of myth and reality is to open at the British Museum next year.Titled Samurai, the blockbuster exhibition will reveal a world beyond armour-clad warriors and epic duels, as popularised by the noble, katana-wielding heroes of Akira Kurosawa’s classic action films and PlayStation’s hit video games.Much of the samurai myth – including even the word “samurai” – was invented long after their heyday, a modern phenomenon linked to mass media and pop culture.The exhibition, which opens in February, will also show that, far from being a male warrior cult, samurai women were educated, governed and even fought.Rosina Buckland, the exhibition’s lead curator, told the Guardian: “This is the first exhibition to tackle the myths